No edit summary |
Amuk (Message Wall | contribs) |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
==First name== |
==First name== |
||
Titles are generally not used in article titles, so '''Principal''' Snyder is not really appropiate. The novel ''[[One Thing or Your Mother]]'' gave Snyder's name as "Cecil". This novel isn't necessarily canon and contradicts Snyder's first initial "R" from the show. Would we be comfortable moving the article to a noncanon title like [[Cecil Snyder]]? I believe the article used to reside at [[R. Snyder]] but was moved for whatever reason. Or should we just keep it the way it is, as Principal Snyder is how the character is best known? [[User:Paul730|Paul730]] 02:55, 14 January 2009 (UTC) |
Titles are generally not used in article titles, so '''Principal''' Snyder is not really appropiate. The novel ''[[One Thing or Your Mother]]'' gave Snyder's name as "Cecil". This novel isn't necessarily canon and contradicts Snyder's first initial "R" from the show. Would we be comfortable moving the article to a noncanon title like [[Cecil Snyder]]? I believe the article used to reside at [[R. Snyder]] but was moved for whatever reason. Or should we just keep it the way it is, as Principal Snyder is how the character is best known? [[User:Paul730|Paul730]] 02:55, 14 January 2009 (UTC) |
||
| + | : I vote for "Principal Snyder". "Cecil" isn't canon and, as you noted, is at least called into question by a canonical source. Avoiding his most common appellation because it's a title would be unduly rigid, methinks. [[User:Amuk|Amuk]] 03:09, 14 January 2009 (UTC) |
||
Revision as of 03:09, 14 January 2009
First name
Titles are generally not used in article titles, so Principal Snyder is not really appropiate. The novel One Thing or Your Mother gave Snyder's name as "Cecil". This novel isn't necessarily canon and contradicts Snyder's first initial "R" from the show. Would we be comfortable moving the article to a noncanon title like Cecil Snyder? I believe the article used to reside at R. Snyder but was moved for whatever reason. Or should we just keep it the way it is, as Principal Snyder is how the character is best known? Paul730 02:55, 14 January 2009 (UTC)
- I vote for "Principal Snyder". "Cecil" isn't canon and, as you noted, is at least called into question by a canonical source. Avoiding his most common appellation because it's a title would be unduly rigid, methinks. Amuk 03:09, 14 January 2009 (UTC)